By Seth Gorton, founder of Searchly. Updated 20 November 2026.
Every time someone searches on Google, an auction decides which ads appear, in what order, and what each advertiser pays. Google ranks the eligible ads by Ad Rank, a score worked out fresh for that one search from your bid, the quality of your ad and landing page, minimum thresholds, how competitive the auction is, the context of the search, and the expected impact of your ad assets. You rarely pay your maximum bid: you pay what it takes to clear the thresholds and beat the advertiser ranked just below you.
That is why a smaller business with a better ad and page can outrank a bigger budget, and why throwing money at bids is the most expensive way to win. This guide explains each part of the auction, what you pay, and the reports that show where you are losing. When we take over a Google Ads account in South Africa, this is the lens we read it through.
The auction, step by step
- Someone in Durban searches “emergency plumber umhlanga”.
- Google finds every ad whose keywords and targeting match that search, location and moment.
- Ads that do not meet minimum quality or policy standards drop out.
- Google calculates Ad Rank for each remaining ad.
- Only ads whose Ad Rank clears the threshold for a position can show there; the rest are ranked below or not shown.
- If someone clicks, the advertiser pays the actual cost per click, which is usually below their maximum bid.
This happens separately for every search. Nothing is reserved in advance, and the same ad can win one auction and lose the next a minute later because the searcher, device or competition changed.

What goes into Ad Rank
Google lists six factors (Google: Ad Rank):
| Factor | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Your bid | The most you are willing to pay for a click, set by you or by Smart Bidding for each auction |
| Quality of your ad and landing page | How relevant and useful Google judges them for this search |
| Ad Rank thresholds | Minimum scores an ad must reach to show at all, or to show above the results |
| Competitiveness of the auction | When competitors’ Ad Ranks are close, positions are harder and dearer to win |
| Context of the search | The words used, location, device, time of day, other ads and results on the page |
| Expected impact of assets | How much sitelinks, call buttons, images and other assets are expected to help |
Where Quality Score fits
Quality Score, the 1 to 10 rating you see per keyword, summarises expected click-through rate, ad relevance and landing page experience. Google is clear that it “is not an input in the ad auction” (About Quality Score). It is a diagnostic: quality is judged afresh in each auction, using far more signals than the score shows. A low score still tells you something real is weak, and fixing it helps Ad Rank. Google no longer describes Ad Rank as “bid times Quality Score”; treat that old formula as a simplification.
What you actually pay
Google charges “what’s minimally required to clear the Ad Rank thresholds” and beat the competitor just below you (Actual cost-per-click). In practice:
- Your maximum bid is a ceiling. The actual cost per click is often lower.
- Thresholds are generally higher for ads shown above the search results, so top positions cost more.
- If yours is the only eligible ad, you pay a reserve price: the threshold rounded up to the minimum billable unit for your currency (Ad Rank thresholds).
- You are not charged more than your maximum cost per click, unless you use automated bidding or bid adjustments, which can take a bid above it.
A simple illustration, not a formula: you set a maximum of R30 a click for “geyser replacement pretoria”. The advertiser below you would win the position with a little less than you, so you might pay R18. Improve your ad and landing page, and the same position can cost less, because your Ad Rank needs less help from the bid.
Why the highest bidder does not always win
Because quality and context count, a well-matched ad can beat a bigger bid. Picture two advertisers on “family law attorney sandton”. One bids high, sends every click to its home page, and its ad mentions every practice area. The other bids less, its ad says “Family law attorney in Sandton”, and the click lands on a page about divorce and custody with a phone number at the top. The second is the more useful result for that searcher, and Google’s quality signals usually reward it with a better position for less money.
The same logic explains why ads sometimes do not show at all. If your ad’s quality is low, the bid needed to clear the threshold can be higher than you are willing to pay, and you are left out of that auction entirely.
Smart Bidding and the auction
With Smart Bidding (Target CPA, Target ROAS, Maximise conversions and similar), Google sets a separate bid for each auction based on how likely that particular search is to convert. Your input is the target and the conversion data, so the quality of your conversion tracking decides how well it bids. If the account counts page views or junk form fills as conversions, Smart Bidding bids up for more of them. Our guide to setting up conversion tracking covers what to count.
The reports that show how you are doing in the auction
Auction insights
For Search campaigns, auction insights shows the other advertisers in your auctions and six measures: impression share, overlap rate, position above rate, top of page rate, absolute top of page rate and outranking share (Auction insights). It tells you who you are up against and whether they are gaining on you. It does not show their bids or budgets.
Impression share lost to budget or to rank
Two columns tell you why you missed auctions you were eligible for (Impression share):
- Search lost IS (budget): the share of eligible searches you missed because the budget ran out. If the campaign is profitable, this is room to grow.
- Search lost IS (rank): the share you missed because your Ad Rank was too low. The fix is better ads, assets, keywords and landing pages, or a higher bid where the numbers justify it.
We check both before any budget conversation. Our guide to setting a Google Ads budget shows how they feed the decision to scale or hold.
What you can control
| Lever | What to do |
|---|---|
| Relevance | Group keywords tightly so each ad matches the searches it shows for |
| Landing page | Send each ad to the page that answers that search, fast on a phone, with a clear next step |
| Assets | Add sitelinks, callouts, call and location assets where they help the searcher |
| Bids and targets | Set from your cost per lead or ROAS, not from what feels competitive |
| Negative keywords | Stop paying to enter auctions you should not be in |
| Conversion tracking | Count real enquiries and sales so Smart Bidding bids for the right auctions |
For the full picture of how campaigns, keywords and the auction fit together, read how Google Ads works, and for what it all costs, how much Google Ads costs in South Africa.
What we see in the accounts we run
Winning the auction for less usually comes from relevance and pages, not bids. At RS Service Centre, a car service and repair business, the account now gets two and a half times the traffic for a third less spend. At BL Aesthetics, a beauty and laser studio, enquiries rose nearly five times on the same budget.
Questions people also ask
Is there a minimum bid?
There is no fixed minimum bid, but there are thresholds. If your ad’s quality is low, the bid needed to clear them rises, and if you are the only eligible advertiser you pay the reserve price.
Does the time of day or device change the auction?
Yes. Device, location and time are part of the context Google weighs in each auction, and competition varies through the day. Your reports, segmented by hour and device, show where your cost per lead is best.
Can I see what competitors bid?
No. Auction insights shows how often you and named competitors appear and outrank each other, but never their bids or budgets.
Want this for your account?
If you spend R15,000 or more a month on Google Ads, start with our 30-day trial. Our management fee is waived for 30 days, and if we have not beaten your current cost per lead or return on ad spend by day 30, you owe us nothing and keep everything we built. That R15,000 is your ad spend, paid to Google; our fee, from R15,000 a month excluding VAT, applies only if you carry on. Start your 30-day trial.

