By Seth Gorton, founder of Searchly. Updated 20 November 2026.
Google Ads reaches people who are already searching for what you sell. Facebook and Instagram ads reach people who fit a profile but are not looking yet. If South Africans search for your service or product by name, start with Google Ads; if what you sell is visual and bought on impulse, a Meta test may come first, and many businesses end up running both with different jobs.

A note on where we stand: Searchly’s services are Google Ads, SEO and CRO; paid social is not offered, so we have a side in this question. That is why this guide spells out when Google is the wrong first choice. If it is the right one, our page on Google Ads management in South Africa explains how we run accounts.
The real difference: intent versus interest
Google Ads captures demand. Someone types “emergency plumber Randburg” or “gearbox repair Midrand” because they need it now. A Search ad appears at that moment, and the search itself tells you what the person wants.

Meta ads create demand. Your ad appears in someone’s Facebook or Instagram feed or Stories because their profile and behaviour suggest they might be interested. They were not looking. The creative has to stop the scroll and make the whole case.
That one difference decides almost everything else: how qualified the leads are, how much creative you need, and how you should judge the results.
Google Ads or Facebook ads at a glance
| Google Ads (Search and Shopping) | Facebook and Instagram ads | |
|---|---|---|
| Who sees the ad | People searching for what you sell | People who match an audience you or Meta choose |
| Main job | Capture demand that already exists | Create demand and build an audience |
| What you need most | Keywords that match real searches, a page that answers them, conversion tracking | Strong images and video, a clear offer, conversion tracking |
| Typical fit | Trades, clinics, legal and financial services, car servicing, B2B, products searched by name | Fashion, décor, beauty, gifts, new products nobody searches for yet |
| How fast leads arrive | Often within days of approval, if people search for it | Depends on how quickly the creative finds an audience |
| Calls, forms and messaging from the ad or landing page | Ads that click to WhatsApp open a chat with your business |
When Google Ads is the better first choice
- People search for what you sell. A plumber, a dentist, an immigration consultant, a car service centre, a supplier of a named product. Check the demand in Google’s Keyword Planner, which estimates monthly searches for a keyword, before you spend anything.
- The need is urgent or the sale is valuable. Someone searching “accountant Sandton” is closer to buying than someone scrolling past a post.
- You sell products online with a clean catalogue. Shopping ads show your product, price and store to people searching for that product.
- You need leads soon. A Search campaign does not have to build an audience first: the searches are already happening.
When Facebook and Instagram ads may suit you better
- Nobody searches for what you sell yet. A new product category, a novelty or an impulse buy has little search demand to capture.
- The product sells on how it looks. Fashion, décor and lifestyle brands can find new customers through images and video.
- You sell through conversation. Meta’s ads that click to WhatsApp run on Facebook and Instagram and open a chat with your business, which suits many South African businesses that close sales on WhatsApp.
Google is not absent from discovery either. Its Demand Gen campaigns run image and video ads across YouTube (including Shorts), Discover, Gmail and the Google Display Network. Our guide to Google Ads campaign types explains where each one fits.
Cheaper clicks are not cheaper customers
Clicks on Facebook and Instagram are usually cheaper than clicks on Google Search. On its own that comparison misleads. What you pay for a customer depends on the price of the click and on how often a click turns into a lead or a sale.
Here is the sum to run on your own numbers. If a Google click costs three times as much as a Meta click but converts ten times as often, the Google lead costs less than a third of the Meta lead. If it converts only twice as often, Meta wins. The only fair test is cost per lead or cost per sale, measured the same way on both platforms. For what clicks actually cost on Google in South Africa, see what Google Ads costs.
How to decide where your budget goes
- Do people search for what you sell, where you sell it? If yes, start with Google Search. If barely, a Meta or Demand Gen test is the better first step.
- How urgent and how valuable is the purchase? The more urgent and the higher the value, the stronger the case for search.
- What creative do you have? Meta and Demand Gen need good photos and video. Search needs ad copy that matches the search and a landing page that answers it.
- Can you measure both the same way? Set up Google Ads conversion tracking and the Meta Pixel on the same actions (a purchase, a completed enquiry form, a booked call) before you compare anything.
- Test with a set budget for each, then move money towards the platform that wins on cost per customer, not on clicks or likes.
We do not recommend fixed splits such as “70% Google, 30% Meta”. The right split depends on search demand, your margins and your creative, and it should move as results come in.
Running both: give each platform one job
- Google Ads: catch people searching now, through Search, Shopping and Performance Max, and remind recent visitors.
- Meta: introduce the brand to people who have not heard of it, and follow up visitors who did not buy with a visual offer or a WhatsApp chat.
Expect the platforms to share credit. Someone who saw an Instagram ad and later searched for your brand on Google will often show up as a Google conversion, and each platform’s own reporting counts generously in its favour. That is why our reports split brand searches from non-brand searches by reading every search term: sales from people who already knew your name are not the same as new customers the ads created.
What we see in the accounts we run
Most of the accounts we take over do not have a platform problem. They have a measurement problem.
- Rooftop on Bree, a Cape Town events venue, had been bidding for clicks for about a year without measuring a single enquiry. Once the account counted enquiries and gave each event type its own page, it reached four times the enquiries in four months.
- BL Aesthetics, a beauty and laser studio, sent every website visitor straight to WhatsApp, so no enquiry could be tied to an ad. A short form that hands over to WhatsApp fixed that, and the account went on to nearly five times the enquiries on the same budget.
- Froggie makes leather footwear in South Africa, the kind of visual product people assume belongs on Instagram. Its Google Ads account had one campaign optimising for map direction requests instead of sales. Bidding for purchases and fixing the product feed brought a fifth more online revenue from the same ad spend.
If you cannot say what a lead costs you on either platform today, fix that before you move budget between them.
If organic search is also on the table, our comparison of SEO and Google Ads covers that decision.
Other questions about Google Ads and Facebook ads
Should a small business choose Google Ads or Facebook ads?
If customers search for your service or product in your area, start with one focused Google Search campaign. If what you sell is discovered rather than searched for, a small Meta test is the better first step. Small budgets work best on one platform at a time.
Which is better for B2B in South Africa?
Usually Google Ads, because buyers search for specific services and suppliers when they have a need. Meta can still help with remarketing to people who have visited your site.
Can I run Google Ads and Facebook ads at the same time?
Yes. Give each a clear job and its own budget, track the same conversions on your website for both, and judge them on the same measure.
Does Google Ads work in smaller South African towns?
Yes, if people there search for what you offer. Location targeting shows your ads in the areas you choose, down to a radius around your business, and Keyword Planner shows whether the searches exist before you spend.
Want this for your account?
Our management fee is waived for 30 days. If we have not beaten your current cost per lead or ROAS by day 30, you owe us nothing and you keep everything we built. The trial is for businesses spending R15,000 or more a month on Google Ads, and it starts with a 15-minute call with Seth.
See the results from our published Google Ads case studies, or call or WhatsApp us on 082 489 8796.

