By Seth Gorton, founder of Searchly. Updated 20 November 2026.
Your SEO is working when more people who did not already know your business find you through Google, and some of them become enquiries or sales. In practice that shows up as rising non-brand clicks in Google Search Console, more searches and pages earning impressions, your most valuable pages moving up, and more organic enquiries or revenue in Google Analytics 4. Rankings alone prove nothing, and neither does traffic that never buys. All six checks below use free Google tools, whether you do SEO yourself or pay an SEO agency.

The six numbers at a glance
| Number | Where to find it | Working looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Non-brand clicks | Search Console, Performance, queries excluding your brand name | Rising, compared with the same period before |
| 2. Organic enquiries or revenue | GA4, key events or revenue for the Organic Search channel | Rising, and matching what reached your inbox or till |
| 3. Impressions and number of queries | Search Console, Performance | More impressions, for more different searches |
| 4. Position of your money pages | Search Console, Performance, filtered by page | Main service or category pages moving up |
| 5. Important pages indexed | Search Console, Page indexing report | Every page you care about indexed |
| 6. Click-through rate on ranking pages | Search Console, Performance, by page | Pages near the top earning their share of clicks |
1. Non-brand clicks: the number most reports leave out
People who search your business name were looking for you already. They would have found you without SEO. The growth that matters comes from people searching for what you do: “emergency plumber Durbanville”, “buy leather sandals online”, “conveyancing attorney Pretoria”.
In Search Console, open Performance, add a query filter that excludes your brand name and its common misspellings, and compare the last three months with the three before, or with the same three months last year if your business is seasonal. Rising non-brand clicks is the clearest single sign that SEO is working. Our Google Search Console tutorial shows where each setting sits.
2. Organic enquiries or revenue
Traffic only matters if it turns into business. In Google Analytics 4, open the Traffic acquisition report and look at key events (form submissions, calls, purchases) or revenue for the Organic Search channel. If your enquiry form or checkout is not marked as a key event, nothing else in this guide can be judged properly; fix it first with our GA4 setup guide.
Then check the number against reality. If GA4 says organic search produced twenty enquiries last month, did twenty arrive? Duplicate tags and spam form fills inflate the number, and you want to know before you judge anyone’s work by it.

3. Impressions and the number of searches you appear for
An impression is Google showing your page in its results. Impressions usually rise before clicks do: a page often appears lower down the results before it reaches a position people click on. If Search Console shows more impressions, for a growing number of different queries, Google is showing your site to more people, even if most of those positions are not yet on page one.
4. The position of the pages that make money
Ignore the site-wide average position. It mixes your homepage, old blog posts and searches you will never convert. Pick the five to ten pages that bring in business (main services, top product categories) and look at each one’s average position over time in the Performance report, filtered by page. A main service page moving from page three to page two is real progress, even before it brings many clicks.
5. Whether your important pages are indexed
A page that is not in Google’s index cannot rank at all. Search Console’s Page indexing report lists pages Google has not indexed and why, such as “Crawled – currently not indexed” or “Discovered – currently not indexed”. Check that every page you care about is indexed, and use the URL Inspection tool on any that are not. A site where most pages are left out is telling you Google sees little value in them, which is a content problem rather than a technical one. Our guide to doing an SEO audit walks through the diagnosis.
6. Click-through rate on pages that already rank
Click-through rate is clicks divided by impressions. If a page sits near the top for a search but few people click, the title and description in the results are not earning the click. Rewriting them is often the quickest improvement available, because the ranking is already there.
What about AI Overviews and AI Mode?
Search Console now has a generative AI performance report showing how often your pages appeared in AI Overviews and AI Mode, by page, country and device. It shows impressions only, with no clicks or queries, and those impressions are already included in your normal totals. Treat it as a sign that Google is citing your pages, not as a traffic number.
How to compare fairly
- Compare like with like. November against October says little for a business that peaks before Christmas. Compare with the same months last year where you can.
- Look at three months, not one. Single months swing with holidays, school terms and Google’s own updates.
- Separate brand from non-brand. A good month for your brand (a radio advert, a mention in the press) can hide a flat month for SEO.
- Note what changed and when. A site redesign, a new page or a migration explains most sudden moves. Keep a short dated log.
Warning signs that something is wrong
- Non-brand clicks flat or falling for several months while the work is supposed to be under way, with no explanation.
- Your main service or category pages are not indexed.
- You cannot find your own business when you search its name.
- Your agency reports only rankings for a hand-picked list of keywords, with no clicks, enquiries or revenue.
- You do not have access to your own Search Console and Analytics accounts.
- Anyone promises you first place. Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO is direct: no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google.
What a good SEO report shows
If you pay for SEO, the report should show these numbers without you asking. Ours, for example, show:
- Organic revenue, orders and sessions from GA4, above the Search Console figures.
- Clicks, impressions, click-through rate, average position and non-brand clicks, with the share of brand searches stated openly.
- The top non-brand searches and the top pages.
- A progress bar on the SEO plan: what is in progress and what is next.
- A dated log, written for you, of what we have been doing, so you never need a call to find out.
Whoever does the work, you should own the Search Console and Analytics accounts and be able to check every figure yourself. That is how we set up every SEO client.
Frequently asked questions
How long before I should see results?
There is no honest fixed answer, and anyone who gives you a guaranteed date is guessing. It depends on how much needs fixing, how competitive your searches are and how quickly Google recrawls your site. Impressions usually move first, then positions, then clicks and enquiries. Our guide to how long SEO takes explains what drives the pace.
My rankings dropped this week. Should I worry?
Small movements up and down are normal. Look at the trend over several weeks and at clicks and enquiries rather than one position. A sharp, lasting drop across many pages at once is worth investigating: check Search Console for manual actions, indexing changes and any recent change to the site.
Can I check all this myself for free?
Yes. Google Search Console and Google Analytics 4 are free and show everything in this guide. Paid tools add competitor data and rank tracking, but Google’s own tools are the most reliable record of how Google sees your site.
Want this for your business?
Tell us about your business and give us read access to Search Console. We will tell you plainly what the numbers say and what we would do first.
Or call or WhatsApp us on 082 489 8796.

